Hester Street Competition Results

Summary Findings The Entries About the Competition Submit Your Ideas
All
Entries
Community
Use
Revenue
Generating
Infra-
structure
Description of Idea

Entry 1
Entry 2
Entry 3
Entry 4
Entry 5
Entry 6
Entry 7
Entry 8
Entry 9
Entry 10
Entry 11
Entry 12
Entry 13
Entry 14
Entry 15
Entry 16
Entry 17
Entry 18
Entry 19
Entry 20
Entry 21
Entry 22
Entry 23
Entry 24
Entry 25
Entry 26
Entry 27
Entry 28
Entry 29
Entry 30
Entry 31
Entry 32
Entry 33
Entry 34
Entry 35
Entry 36
Entry 37
Entry 38
Entry 39
Entry 40
Entry 41
Entry 42
Entry 43
Entry 44
Entry 45
Entry 46
Entry 47
Entry 48
Entry 49
Entry 50
Entry 51
Entry 52
Entry 53
Entry 54
Entry 55
Entry 56
Entry 57
Entry 58

Entry 1
Entry 2
Entry 3
Entry 4
Entry 5
Entry 7
Entry 8
Entry 9
Entry 10
Entry 11
Entry 12
Entry 13
Entry 14
Entry 15
Entry 16
Entry 18
Entry 20
Entry 22
Entry 25
Entry 26
Entry 28
Entry 29
Entry 31
Entry 32
Entry 33
Entry 34
Entry 35
Entry 36
Entry 37
Entry 38
Entry 39
Entry 40
Entry 42
Entry 43
Entry 44
Entry 46
Entry 47
Entry 48
Entry 49
Entry 50
Entry 51
Entry 52
Entry 53
Entry 55
Entry 56
Entry 57
Entry 58

Entry 1
Entry 3
Entry 6
Entry 9
Entry 11
Entry 17
Entry 19
Entry 24
Entry 25
Entry 29
Entry 31
Entry 36
Entry 41
Entry 44
Entry 45
Entry 47
Entry 48
Entry 49
Entry 51
Entry 53
Entry 54

Entry 18
Entry 21
Entry 23
Entry 27
Entry 30

Entry 5

My apartment directly faces this space, and I recall a shallow blue pool in this space many years ago--it looked beautiful against the trees. I suggest a community garden built around a water theme: fountain/s inside a shallow blue painted pool, surrounded by lovely grasses (Battery Park style) and plants and a ring of benches around the fountain. The water sound would create tranquility and mask the noise from Essex. The garden and fountain and pool would be a lovely sight from Buildings 3 and 4 apartments and from the street. But keep it walled off from Essex St. with a brick and iron fence to keep swirling papers and trash from making it dirty. We also need direct access to Essex St. but I wouldn't put it here or the gate will soon give access to people on the street. As a child, I lived in 504 Grand St (Amalgamated) and the fountain inside the central courtyard was the nicest feature of the building and created a real sense of community -- mothers strolled their babies around the fountain, and it was a peaceful and safe place for children to congregate. I like dogs but we need a park for residents more than a dog run. We also need Essex access but not from the park.

I'm enclosing a photograph of the 504 Grand St. courtyard with the central fountain at 504 Grand St., for those of you who haven't seen it. It illustrates how water in the center of trees and a small park creates a peaceful and unifying setting. Of course, it helps that it's totally enclosed by a six story building with a north view of Broome St. through the largest arch as the only break in enclosure. (There are also two smaller arches, not shown, which lead to staircases up to Grand ST on the west side and Willet St on the east.) The pool with fountain at 504 is just a couple of feet deep, not meant for swimming or dangling one's feet. I don't recall seeing anyone in the pool. In spring it was surrounded by tulips, and when leaves from the surrounding trees fell into the pool, it looked nice (maybe we could have water lilies!). It's been there since 1930, and I've never heard of any child drowning.

What makes it work is the sense of enclosure with only an arched view to the street (I think the main gate to the building is now at that arch). Depending on the size of the Hester St parcel, it might be important to give it a sense of enclosure, either with surround trees and/or a low brick wall.

I know a gate or access to Essex is important to many and if you are considering combining it with the park, I would argue it should be placed in a separate place, not the middle of the park. Even entering our buildings, when you open the door, it is just impossible to keep people you don't know from walking in behind you -- what can you do to stop them from coming in, if they've been waiting in the lobby, or arrived when you did? So even with security facing our building doorways, it's impossible to keep them out. If we had a gate at the park (or elsewhere) on Hester St, every time someone walked through it to enter or leave Essex St, it's inevitable that outsiders will walk in. And we don't have security there to ask who they are. I think this creates a potentially dangerous arrangement. Imagine someone walking back to building 3 or 4 through a gate on Essex Street, especially at night, but even in the4 day. No security guard and possibly no one in the area, they could easily be followed by someone they couldn't prevent from walking in -- it's a perfect setup for a mugging -- esp. at night. And apart from security considerations, at the minimum, it allows outsiders to come in and use the park. If we keep the entrance and park open to view with only an iron gate, all the trash and garbage from people walking by on Essex will be tossed or blown into the park. Take a look along that fence on Essex and you will see the trash (or I remember how it accumulated before the running track was installed). So maybe we should keep the park enclosed with trees or a low brick wall, and put the gate to Essex somewhere else, where it may be more open to view and with an iron gate.